|

The 3rd James F. Ackerman Colloquium on Technology and
Citizenship Education:
"Citizenship Education 2.0: Digital Media in a Networked
World"
June 18-20, 2009
Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN
June 18, 2009
Participants arrive by 4:00 p.m. Registration and check in
Union Club Hotel lobby Reception begins at 5:30 p.m. (Anniversary
Drawing Room, Purdue Memorial Union) Welcome: Phillip J. VanFossen and Michael J. Berson
DINNER 6:00 p.m. (Anniversary Drawing Room, Purdue
Memorial Union)
Colloquium Introduction: Phillip VanFossen, Director,
Ackerman Center (.ppt)
KEYNOTE 1:
Anne Collier, Writer and Journalist,
NetFamily News Inc.
(.ppt)
June 19, 2009
BREAKFAST (7:30 – 8:15 a.m.) Stewart Center 311
Announcements/’Day-at-a-Glance’
8:15 - 9:45
a.m.
Session 1:
Discussion Leader - Daniel W. Stuckart, Wagner College
|
Paper Title: Using VoiceThread
as a Debate Tool (.ppt)
(.doc)
Author: Adam Friedman, Wake Forest University
& John K. Lee, North Carolina State
University
In this paper, we present
the results of a quasi-experimental study that measures
the utility of Voicethread (http://voicethread.com) for
facilitating debate in middle and high school social
studies. Emerging theory related to technological
pedagogical content knowledge served as a contextual
frame for our study. Students in control classes engaged
in a traditional, whole-class debate, while experimental
classes participated in debates using Voicethread. Data
consisted of pre- and post-tests, observations,
interviews, and student products. This session will
involve an overview of Voicethread and a presentation of
findings from the study. In addition, we will offer some
practical tips and considerations for integrating
Voicethread in the K-12 environment.
| | |
|
Paper Title: Primary Access: Overview of
Research and Directions for Future Study
Author: Tom Hammond, Lehigh University (link)
PrimaryAccess (www.primaryaccess.org)
is a suite of free, online tools for social studies education that
allow users to manipulate digitized primary sources. Using
PrimaryAccess, students and teachers can browse an index of
contextualized digital images and then compose digital
documentaries or comic strips, or even construct rebuses. Teachers
can set up student accounts, design activities, and share these
activities to students. The presentation will provide an
introduction to the PrimaryAccess suite of tools, demonstrating
their use and explaining the decisions that occurred during the
design process. This introduction will be followed by an overview
of the research efforts and findings on using PrimaryAccess in
K-12 social studies classrooms to date, focusing on digital
documentary creation. The audience is invited not only to critique
the research but to consider this introduction and overview as an
invitation to collaborate on future research.
|
|
BREAK
10:00 – 11:45 a.m.
Session 2:
Discussion Leaders -
Peggy
O'Neill-Jones, Metropolitan State College of
Denver
Caroline Sheffield, University of
Louisville |
|
Paper Title: Digital
Historical Inquiry in the US History Classroom: Comparing Modes of
Instruction
Author:
Meghan McGlinn Manfra, North Carolina State
University
This research proposal
focuses on secondary US history instruction (grades 11-12) in a
high-stakes testing environment. Previous research in this field
demonstrates that students learn best in a social environment and
that deep content knowledge can be learned through disciplined
inquiry into authentic historical problems (Bransford, Brown, &
Pelligrino, 2000; Scheurman & Newmann, 1998; Wineberg, 2001).
However, history teachers report feeling constrained in their
curricular options due to high stakes testing (Grant, 2003). They
tend to favor transmission (Stanley, 2005) or “mimetic” models of
instruction and coverage of content (Drake & Nelson, 2009);
students are encouraged to memorize and recite (Barton & Levstik,
2003). Working alongside a US history teacher, I planned two
units of instruction that engaged students in authentic historical
work using digital history materials, including digitized primary
sources. Student outcomes in this instructional model were
compared to those of a more traditional, transmission-oriented
pedagogical model. Based on the findings, I hope to learn how we
can support teachers in their integration of inquiry and
multi-media in the social studies classroom and to change teacher
perceptions about their curricular options.
|
|
Paper Title:
Transforming Students'
International Experiences through the use of Web 2.0 Tools
Authors:
Tim Newby and Peg Ertmer, Purdue University (.ppt)
We live in a world characterized by globalization,
emerging new technologies, and a knowledge-based economy. Given
these realities, future teachers must be both digitally literate
and globally competent, possessing effective communication,
collaboration, and problem-solving skills. The Web 2.0 project
described here was designed to provide every teacher education
student at Purdue University with an international learning
experience using Web 2.0 technologies. An initial pilot was
conducted during Fall 2008 with 285 preservice teachers, enrolled
in EDCI 27000 (Introduction to Educational Technology), along with
43 international partners (IPs) from Turkey and South Korea
(students were divided into 34 teams, with 3-4 IP students on each
of 12 different teams). A second pilot occurred in Spring 2009
with 346 Purdue students, divided into 43 teams, and including 135
IPs from China, Australia, Singapore, and Taiwan.
During both semesters, teams worked collaboratively to create a
wiki chapter about an assigned Web 2.0 technology. In addition,
students were required to present information about their
applications at a public poster session, including relevant
educational applications and lesson plans (see
http://wiki.itap.purdue.edu/display/INSITE/INSITE+MAIN for
sample chapters). Comparisons between pre- and post-survey data
suggest that the project experience had positive impacts on
students’ perceptions of their confidence for using various Web
2.0 technologies in the classroom, as well as their perceived
importance for these same technologies. Implications will be
discussed regarding continued use of Web 2.0 technologies to
connect students across the globe.
LUNCH (12:00 – 1:30 p.m.)
1:30 – 2:45 p.m. (Beering Hall;
B280)
Session 3: Hands-on session in
lab
Discussion Leader -
Richard Diem, The University of Texas at San
Antonio
|
|
Paper Title: Capturing
the Teachable Moment: Using Flip Video Cameras to Promote Civic
Education
(.ppt)
Author:
George Lipscomb, Furman
University
While video has been present in K-12
social studies classrooms for many years, the technical knowledge
needed to use and edit footage has become significantly easier in
recent years. One new innovation, The “Flip” video camera, is
changing the way teachers use video and share ideas beyond their
classrooms. In this hands-on session, participants will learn how
to use these cameras, look at editing possibilities with Flip
software, and explore potential applications in civic
education. |
|
Paper Title: Using Blogs
to extend Teaching, Learning, and Research in Social Studies
Education (link)
Author:
Alicia Crowe, Kent State
University
The popularity
of blogs has increased exponentially in the last ten years. In
this short time, blogs have begun to take many forms and styles
and serve many purposes. Blogs can now be designed to allow
readers to take on a more active role or for one blog to have
multiple authors. As blogs have become a part of the everyday life
in a society proliferated by electronic information communication
tools, so have they become a part of the lives of citizens. This
tool has become a way to be political as well as a way to
democratize access to information. This means that educators must
begin to think differently about how to help their students learn
about the world they are living in. Some teachers are beginning to
do this by using blogs as a part of their teaching.
Besides helping
young citizens learn how to read, interpret and judge the
information presented in a blog, social studies educators can also
take advantage of this tool to enhance the learning community they
have already established and expand classroom conversations beyond
the confines of the school day and building. During this hands-on
session we will explore how to create a blog, how some social
studies educators have used this tool to breakdown the walls of
their classrooms (high school and university) and how blogs can be
used to help social studies educators support one another as they
engage in inquiry into their teaching. We will also discuss
questions around the creation and use of blogs and how this tool
might be used to democratize teaching, learning, and research. If
you have used blogs in your teaching or research, please feel
welcome to add your experiences to the conversation.
BREAK
3:00 – 4:15 p.m.
Session 4: Hands-on session in
lab “Day in Review/Things to Think
About…”
Discussion
Leader -
James Shively, Miami University
|
|
Paper Title:
Emerging Trends in the Use of Social Media in
Commercial Virtual Schools
(.ppt)
Author:
Bob Keller
It is estimated that over 1 million
students were enrolled in K-12 online courses during the 2007-8
school year. Approximately 75% of school districts report that
some or all of their K-12 students will take at least one online
course in the coming school year. Virtual courses-which were once
strictly static experiences allowing only limited connectivity to
other students and outside resources-are evolving to a more
student-controlled, interactive, and collaborative model.
Independent of the virtual education environment, the social media
revolution is transforming young people's means of communication
and is affecting their patterns of socialization and participation
in society. As a result, virtual school enterprises are aware of
the need for the "new" socialization skills and they are seizing
opportunities presented by technological advances in virtual
school platforms to include social media in online courses.
Contributing to these advances, are huge improvements in the
graphic interfaces for the courses and the ability to mix
synchronous and asynchronous class experiences.
This presentation looks at emerging uses of
social networking tools in the virtual school setting. Are they
"add ons" being included strictly for commercial appeal, or are
they serving a valid educational purpose? What are the
implications for the student experience and the teacher
experience? In particular, the presentation will consider how
collaborative tools such as blogs, wikis, podcasting, image and
video sharing, polling, mobile technology, social networking
sites, aggregators, social bookmarking, multi-player online
gaming, web conferencing, simulations, and open education
resources are being used in the new generation of online courses.
The presentation will open discussion of the issues around the use
of social media to teach and apply citizenship and participatory
skills.
|
|
Paper Title: GIS/Google Earth
Activity
Author: Tom Hammond, Lehigh
University
The proliferation of complex,
geographically-referenced issues such as immigration, climate
change, and pandemic diseases has spurred interest in geographic
understanding and geospatial tools. Unfortunately, the content,
pedagogy, and technology of geospatial tools is each "wickedly"
complex (Koehler & Mishra, 2008; White, 2005)--the tools have
tremendous potential, but require a steep investment in training,
planning time, instructional time, and the space to develop
pedagogical expertise. This hands-on activity will provide
participants with a simple, concrete experience in using
geospatial tools to address geographic understanding and skills.
This practical introduction will be followed by a presentation of
these tools and techniques in the context of a larger
instructional sequence of geospatial inquiry about the local
environment. Time will be reserved for discussion and critique of
the tools and teaching techniques used. Participants with GPS
units or GPS-enabled cellphones are encouraged to bring them
along, and those with prior experience teaching with geospatial
technologies are encouraged to share their expertise!
DINNER 6:00 p.m. (Anniversary Drawing Room, Purdue Memorial Union)
KEYNOTE 2: "Social
Computing Philosophy and Tools: An Overview" (.ppt)
Johannes Strobel, Assistant Professor of
Engineering Education and Educational Technology, Purdue
University
June 20,
2009
BREAKFAST (7:30 – 8:15 a.m.) Stewart Center 218C
Announcements/’Day-at-a-Glance’
8:15 – 10:00 a.m.
Session 5:
Discussion Leader -
Scott M. Waring, University of Central
Florida
|
|
Paper Title:
Legislative Aide –
Social Networking for Civic Action
Authors:
Kerry D. Poole &
Michael J. Berson, University of South
Florida
Civics education in the United States often is designated
as a low priority in the curriculum and is typically characterized
by passive, rote learning that is centered around content and
materials provided by textbook companies. Results from recent
assessments of America’s students suggest that the current
generation possesses only a superficial knowledge of civics and is
less engaged in traditional political activities.
Service-learning, a method that combines community service with
classroom learning objectives, is being widely implemented in
schools across the nation because of research findings that report
associated increases in the acquisition of academic skills and
knowledge, greater student engagement in their studies, and
enhanced motivation to learn. Some educators are looking beyond
traditional methods of instruction and exploring how technology,
computing, and gaming may be integrated with student learning,
including service-learning. Community Knowledgebase, LLP, a firm
created at the University of Wisconsin by Professor Lewis
Friedland, has developed software to support community-based
research and service-learning. The software is based on the
epistemic games research of David Williamson Shaffer in which
young people use software tools to play roles that parallel adult
professions. The current version is called Legislative Aide and is
being tested in Hillsborough County Schools in Florida through a
partnership between CIRCLE, Community Knowledgebase, University of
South Florida, and the School District of Hillsborough County. A
pilot, funded by the Department of Education, is being implemented
from January to June 2009. In participating high schools, students
role play as aides to an imaginary local elected official in a
virtual legislative office. The students use the software to
assist them in investigating real community problems and proposing
real community action plans to address the problems. Researchers
are collecting implementation and outcome data throughout the
pilot to guide improvements to the program. They eventually plan
to make the program available on a larger scale to schools
throughout the nation.
|
|
Paper Title:
Learning
by Doing: A Constructionist Approach to Social Studies Simulation
Games
Author:
Joseph R. Feinberg, Georgia State University
Instructional
simulation games are powerful models of the real world that allow
students to interact with events and objects that are normally
inaccessible within a classroom setting. Yet, simply using an
instructional simulation ignores powerful learning opportunities.
Papert (1991) advocates going beyond simply using model. He
promotes a fundamental change in how children learn through his
theory of constructionism. Instead of constructivism with a “v,”
Papert advocates a theory of learning called constructionism with
an “n.” Constructionism borrows from constructivist theory that
learners actively construct knowledge from their experiences. But
constructionism adds that new ideas are more likely to emerge when
learners are actively engaged in designing or building an artifact
or physical model that can be reflected upon and shared with
others. Web 2.0 offers many opportunities for students to build
and share with others. In this presentation, the potential
application of constructionism for social studies simulations will
be shared and discussed with the implications of learning by
doing.
|
|
Paper
Title:
Tools for Digital Storytelling: Connecting
Students to their CommunityAuthor: Krista Glazewski &
Christian McKay, New Mexico State
University
Digital storytelling supports a
variety of learning goals, including those that focus on both
content and technology outcomes. In addition, digital storytelling
may be used to connect students to their surrounding community and
environment. In this presentation, we will demonstrate tools for
digital storytelling, to include tools for film and soundscape
production. We will also discuss use of these tools in the context
of FilmKids, an afterschool storytelling project for upper
elementary and middle school students.
|
|
BREAK
10:15 – 11:45 a.m.
Session 6:
Discussion
Leader - Linda Bennett, University of
Missouri
|
|
Paper Title:
Microscopes and Telescopes:
A Research Agenda for Studying Web 2.0 Learning Environments in the
Social Studies and Beyond (.ppt)
(.doc)
Author:
Justin Reich, Harvard
Graduate School of Education
Web 2.0 technologies are transforming
the civic and economic spheres, and educators are creating online
learning environments with blogs, wikis and social networks as at
an exponential rate. Web 2.0 platforms offer promising
opportunities for students to develop 21st century
skills such as critical thinking, complex communication, and new
media literacies, and they offer important new opportunities for
researchers. Since publically hosted blogs and wikis create
accessible historical records of activity, they represent an
enormous new database of millions of student-teacher interactions
available for investigation. The possibilities for new
methodologies in social studies research are diverse and exciting.
This paper proposes an agenda for social studies researchers to
holistically investigate social media through observational
research, computational simulation, content analysis, the
development of quality instruments, computational semantic
analysis, and longitudinal statistical research. Through these
diverse techniques, researchers will be able to study individual
learning environments under microscopes and the universe of social
media in the social studies through telescopes.
|
|
Paper Title: Participatory
Media & Civic Education: Refocusing Social Use of Web 2.0 for
Academic Purposes
(.doc)
(.ppt)
Author: Joe O'Brien, University of Kansas
Since classroom based online civic education requires the use
of privately and commercially operated virtual places to serve
public purposes, teachers end up building a participatory
media-rich civic learning environment for students on an ad hoc
basis. We as civic educators are obligated to help teachers bring
some coherence to students’ online virtual civic experiences. As
Bull et al (2008) noted though "teachers have limited models for
effective integration of media in their teaching" and "only
limited research is available to guide best practice" (p. 2). I
will draw upon the "limited research" so as to suggest ways for
the effective integration of [participatory] media" in civic
education. Prior to making the suggestions, I will highlight
different conceptions of citizenship and the importance of
developing civic participatory skills, the growing digital
disconnect between students’ online out-of-school experiences and
their offline in-school experiences, the emergence of
participatory media and the blurring of the lines between the
personal, public and commercial sectors, and ways to transfer
students’ informal, social learning related to their use of
participatory media to formal, academic learning.
|
|
LUNCH (12 – 12:45 p.m.)
- Discussion: Next steps? Where do we go from
here? | |